Latt,
Agree with all you are saying there friend.
Sometimes I think it is just hard for new sengers to see the value of good stewardship until they have been around long enough to see it pay off.
In 2008 my nephew approached me about learning how to seng and I gladly took him up on that. Young new sengers - especially if they are in need of cash can easily get greedy and not dig it right. Like digging a few two prongs as they go along or not taking the time to plant the berries. They just get excited and go for the root and toss the top down and move on looking for another.
In 2008 and 2009 I had to fuss on him quite a bit for that and just kept explaining how in the future it would work out much better for us if he did that right.
Then finally this year came 2010 and we hunted a few hollows that we hunted in 2008 again and because we practiced good stewardship then we came out of the woods with about the same amount of seng we harvested in 2008. Found lots of nice 3 prongers and an occasional 4.
The longer time goes on and the more times we hunt those same hollows agian (every 2 or 3 years) have as much fun, collecting a nice pile of mature roots each time the more that good stewardship practice will sink into his very nature as a seng hunter.
One of these days he may be taking my son or grandson and fussing on him for digging an occasional 2 prong or forgetting to plant the berries
Good Stewardship in most cases I think has to come with the wisdom that time passes on to the seng hunter actually seeing the good or bad results of their actions.
PS - on that long handle digger. Once you try one you will probably never go back to a short handle tool. I know that both Billy and I can say that.
I dug seng for many years (probably 20+) with a flat head, then eventually found a very small pick mattox tool that had about a 14\" handle and used that for many years (until it broke), then about 5 years ago tried out this long handle hoe and basically fell in love with it compared to the others.
It does a great job of digging seng, but also serves as a walking stick, weed/briar beater, snake tamer, a dog will sure respect you when you have that tool in your hand and I have found it to be very necessary for helping get around on very steep hillsides - like the blufs I like to hunt on. You can hook the blade around a sapling or root or just slam the hoe head in the ground and help pull your self up and around on those very steep places.
A few weeks ago while fishing I came to a spot where there was a bluff that faced north and tried to climb up there and look around for some seng. I did not have my digger with me and found it to be extremely difficult to get around on that bluff without it.
Good Luck in finding a good long handle tool to try out.
TNhunter